Main Content

The Mathias Team

Specializing in Personal Services and
Extraordinary Results

Explore Compass
Agent
Welcome

The Mathias Team

Always providing Personal Service with Extraordinary Results!

The Mathias Team is a collaboration of local Realtors working together towards one goal - helping our clients meet their personal real estate needs.

Utilizing over 85+ combined years of experience & knowledge, we understand that selling a house is more than just estimates and market trends. It's about learning our client's specific housing goals and needs to develop a personalized strategy to meet those goals.

Providing insight, advice, and honest communication, we strive to help clients make informed decisions in their best interest. We believe that personal service can achieve extraordinary results.

Certifications and recognitions:

  • REALTOR® certification
  • Members National Association of Realtors
  • Members Ohio Association of Realtors
  • Members Columbus Board of Realtors
  • Members Greater Dublin Realtor Association
  • Certified Relocation Specialists
  • Certified e-Pro Internet Specialist
  • Certified Marketing Specialists
  • Certified Negotiation Specialists
  • Top 1% Coldwell Banker Agents Worldwide
  • Columbus Board of Realtors $25 Million Club
  • Cartus Relocation Certified
  • Certified E-Marketing Specialists
  • OAR Pinnacle of Performance Award
Our Numbers

Why Work With Us

100%
Customer
Satisfaction
Logo
38
Years In The
Business
Logo
89%
Percentage of
Business from past
Client referrals
Logo
1,381+
Clients
Serviced
Logo
Map Transparent dublin powell worthington westerville new-albany clintonville upper-arlington hilliard grandview downtown Map Base
Communities

Areas of Expertise

Please click on any community for local information and listings.

Dublin
Dublin
Powell
Powell
Upper
Arlington
Upper Arlington
Worthington
Worthington
Clintonville
Clintonville
Hilliard
Hilliard
Grandview
Grandview
Downtown
Downtown
Westerville
Westerville
New Albany
New Albany
Communities

Areas of Experties

Please click on any community for local information and listings.

Quote
Testimonials

What Our Clients Say

We recently had the pleasure of working with Neil as our buyer’s agent, and we couldn’t be more satisfied with the experience. Neil and his team were fantastic! Neil's deep insight into the local market in the greater Columbus, Ohio area was invaluable. He came highly recommended with great references, and he certainly lived up to his reputation. He made the entire process smooth and stress-free for us. From the get-go, Neil was friendly, approachable, transparent, and incredibly easy ...

M. William Martin

Neil Mathias and his team recently helped me purchase another investment property. His market knowledge and negotiating skills helped us get a great value and close the deal in less than 1 week, while beating out another offer. I have worked with many realtors over the years. Neil is hands down one of the best in the greater Columbus area. He is a fantastic communicator and you can tell he truly cares about his clients and their investments. Thank you Neil for an easy professional transaction! P...

Ryan Crossley

Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard. The decision to use the Mathias team to sell our home was the best decision we made. Neil and his entire team treated us like family as we journeyed through the entire process. I would highly recommend using this no pressure, highly professional team for your house hunting or selling experience. They will not disappoint.

Lonnie & Lynne McLaughlin

Neil was very knowledgeable about many aspects of homes, including basic construction, architecture and what could or could not be changed. He really listened to our concerns, wants, and was very patient with us through the entire process.

Sarah Graham

I am a senior & a widow. My present home has become too much for me to maintain. I just purchased a smaller condo & the entire process went extremely smoothly. I give all the credit to the Mathias Team of realtors. The Mathias team helped & supported me through the entire process. The home I am selling was photographed beautifully & the brochures & on line video made my condo a show place. I had ten showings in three days & received two offers. The Mathias Team found me a new home & sold my curr...

Becky Stentz

Kelsea was a great help for us in selling our home. From the first conversation, she was focused on what we wanted and needed. Along the way she communicated frequently and kept us in the loop. Selling our home could have been a stressful experience, but Kelsea made it easy!

Adam and Arielle S

Neil did a walk-thru(on his own) at our new house and pointed out some items that the builder needed to fix. He did this prior to the official walk-thru with the builder which was very helpful and very much appreciated!

Dan & Annette Wiblin

We were thrilled the sale of our house happened so quickly. Neil did a wonderful job giving us input on upgrades to make before listing. Neil was exceptional at keeping us informed and up to date on what was happening with our sale.

Tom & Jen Peck

When you hire a realtor to sell you home, the objective is usually the same; sell our home at the price we asked as quickly as possible. But it's never that easy. Decisions have to be made regarding upgrades or changes to the property and the price for the property. Neil came in and made several minor suggestions that would help sell the home. We agreed on the price and on the first day the listing went live, we had a cash offer at the price we asked. Mission accomplished! Neil was a pleasure to...

Mike Johnson

Neil was with us every step of the way. Always available and able to answer any questions about the building process and even layout and design. We knew we were well taken care of with Neil and his team!

Janie Estes

See us on

Instagram

Follow us on Instagram for the most exclusive real estate news and photos from our amazing listings with updates and more.

Skip to content